Android’s AirTag Alternative Falls a Bit Short – Pebblebee Clip Review

I’ve been closely following the rollout of Google’s version of Apple’s “Find My Device” network and recently had the opportunity to review one of the first products to support this ecosystem: the Pebblebee Clip. You can see how it works in my latest review.

This device, retailing for about $30 (compensated affiliate link), aims to bring Android users a tracking solution akin to Apple’s AirTag. In theory, any updated Android phone can detect these trackers and report their location back to Google. However, my initial tests revealed some shortcomings.

Setting up the Pebblebee Clip was not as seamless as expected. I had to uninstall and reinstall the Find My Device app on my Google Pixel 8a to get it working. The device pairs over Bluetooth and features a rechargeable battery, a departure from the replaceable watch batteries used in many trackers, including AirTags. The battery life is advertised to last about a year, though this will vary based on usage.

One significant feature of the Pebblebee Clip is its anti-stalking capability. Google mandates that these devices notify people if they are being followed by a tag not in the owner’s possession. This feature is supposed to work across both Android and iOS devices. However, in my tests, it did not function as intended. When my wife carried the tag around with her iPhone for the better part of the day, she received no notifications, indicating a possible issue with the current implementation.

The user interface for the Pebblebee Clip allows for tracking the device, playing a sound to locate it, and even features a light to assist in finding it in the dark. It also provides a hot and cold directional indicator to help users find the tag when they are close by, although it lacks the precision of Apple’s ultra-wideband technology.

A significant limitation of the Google network is the default setting on Android phones. By default, the phones only participate in the network in “high-traffic” areas where there are a number of other Android phones present in the environment. This setting severely limits the effectiveness of the network in suburban or rural areas. When my wife took the tag to various locations where presumably other Android users would be present, including a grocery store and an art show, I received no location updates until she returned home.

Furthermore, the Pebblebee Clip lacks a “left behind” notification feature, which is present in Apple’s system. This feature alerts users when they move away from their tagged items, such as a bag. Additionally, the RFID scanning feature, which is supposed to allow users to tap the tag against their phone to get the owner’s information, did not work on either my Google or Apple devices in my testing.

Overall, while the Pebblebee Clip has some promising features, it falls short due to the limitations of Google’s network. The default settings and lack of universal device reporting significantly hinder its effectiveness, especially in less densely populated areas. For those in urban environments, it may perform adequately, but for others, Apple’s AirTag remains a more reliable option. Google’s network needs to be more robust and universally accessible to truly compete. Until then, the Pebblebee Clip is an interesting device that highlights the potential and current limitations of Google’s “Find My Device” network.

Many users wrote in to say that I “forgot” Samsung Tags that also have a similar find my device network. I didn’t forget and know it exists.. The point here is that Google is building a network that should work across the entire Android ecosystem – not just Samsung. And it falls short.

Exploring Inexpensive Generic AirTag Alternatives

Apple’s AirTag tracker has turned into a major hit due to its low cost (for an Apple product anyway) and the fact that it can operate for months accurately reporting its position without needing a monthly fee or a nightly battery recharge.

In my latest video I take a look at some licensed generic alternatives to Apple’s AirTag that work mostly the same way but can sometimes be found for half the price.

These low cost tags can be found on Amazon by searching for “Find My” trackers. Here’s an Amazon idea list of a few that I featured in my review (affiliate link).

Most of the trackers you’ll encounter are similar in form factor to Apple’s offering, although many come with an accessory like a keyring, dog collar, etc. for less than what you’d pay for an Apple AirTag and accessory combined. Additional savings can be had by seeking out bulk packs of these trackers that are also available on site.

There’s other form factors available too. One device in my video is the same size and shape as a stack of three credit cards and is designed to track the location of your wallet. Another called the Pincard is completely sealed and weatherproof but can recharge using any Qi wireless charger.

While these third party devices share many features with Apple’s AirTag, including utilizing the Find My network for tracking, they lack the Ultra-Wideband technology present on the official device. This means the precision in locating the devices, especially in the critical last few feet, isn’t as refined. Despite this, the presence of audible alerts on most third-party trackers somewhat mitigates this limitation.

None of these products rival the quality of Apple’s offering but they all seem to perform quite well. If you have a number of things to keep track of you can dramatically grow the size of your tracked item list while saving some money in the process.

Disclaimer: the tags in the video came in free of charge through the Amazon Vine program. This video was not sponsored nor did anyone approve or review the video before it was uploaded.